Should I Drive Traffic to My Website or Amazon?

"Should I drive traffic to my website or Amazon" is the question every multi-channel seller asks. The honest answer is "calculate net margin per channel, then split traffic accordingly." This guide breaks down the math, the trade-offs, and the right balance by seller stage.

If you have been defaulting to one channel without checking the math, the framework below shows you the honest comparison.

Across hundreds of AI tool runs on SellerShorts, the recommendations below are the ones that recur on listings that hit measurable lift.

From the SellerShorts editorial desk. SellerShorts runs an AI tool marketplace built for Amazon sellers.

The honest answer: it depends on margin per channel

Conversion rate: Amazon vs own website

• Amazon: 5-15 percent typical for external traffic. Pre-existing Prime trust lifts conversion.
• Own website: 1-3 percent typical. Same as open-web ecommerce benchmark.
• Gap explanation: Amazon shoppers trust the marketplace (returns, Prime shipping, review system). External traffic landing on your site has no built-in trust signal.
• Exception: Email subscribers and returning customers convert better on your own website (they already trust your brand).

Margin comparison after fees

• Amazon: referral fee (most commonly 15 percent; ranges 8 to 45 percent by category per Amazon's fee schedule) plus a flat per-unit FBA fulfillment fee based on product size tier and weight (small-standard items typically $2.43 to $4.22 per unit in 2026, plus a 3.5 percent fuel surcharge effective April 2026). Revenue retained after Amazon fees typically lands at 65 to 77 percent of selling price for standard-size items; actual net profit margin depends on COGS, ad spend, and overhead and is usually meaningfully lower than retained revenue.
• Own website: 2-3 percent payment processing only. Net margin closer to 95-97 percent of selling price (assuming 30 percent gross margin).
• Net difference: Own website preserves 20-30 percent more revenue per sale than Amazon for the same product.

Brand Referral Bonus changes the math

• Brand Registry sellers earn 10 percent bonus on Amazon sales from properly-tagged external traffic.
• Effective Amazon fee on external traffic sales: roughly 5-25 percent instead of 15-35 percent.
• Combined with 3-5x higher conversion, Amazon often wins on total revenue per dollar of external traffic.
• Setup: Use Amazon Attribution (Brand Registry) to tag external links; bonus auto-credits to your account.

When driving traffic to your own website wins

Here is the timing picture in practice.

• Building email list and customer relationship. Repeat purchase compounds over months.
• Custom packaging and unboxing experience. Amazon FBA standardizes packaging; own fulfillment lets you customize.
• Very thin margin categories. Amazon fees push net margin under 20 percent.
• Strong brand identity that justifies premium pricing on own site. Higher selling price on website than Amazon possible for premium brands.
• International customers in markets without strong Amazon presence. Own site bypasses marketplace gaps.

Our Amazon Listing Optimizer takes an ASIN and returns a full optimized listing (title, bullets, description, backend keywords, plus keyword strategy and competitor gaps) in one run. Push live to Seller Central in one click.

When driving traffic to Amazon wins

Here is what shifts the timing decision.

• Cold external traffic that does not know your brand. Amazon trust signal converts 3-5x better than standalone site.
• Categories with strong Prime preference. Buyers explicitly filter for Prime; non-Prime listings get skipped.
• Brand Registry with Brand Referral Bonus. 10 percent bonus offsets Amazon fees by a meaningful margin.
• SKUs where you cannot match Amazon's fulfillment speed. 2-day Prime delivery vs your standard 5-7 day shipping.
• Sellers without their own fulfillment infrastructure. Building own site requires fulfillment plus customer service investment.

The right traffic split by seller stage

• New sellers (under 100 reviews): 80 percent Amazon. Faster proof of product-market fit; Amazon's trust signal carries new brands.
• Growth-stage (100-1,000 reviews): 60-70 percent Amazon, 30-40 percent website. Start building customer relationships.
• Mature brands (1,000 plus reviews): 50-50 split. Own website becomes meaningful share of revenue; protects against platform risk.
• Established with strong brand: 40-50 percent website, 50-60 percent Amazon. Brand authority drives direct traffic.

How to track conversion per channel

Below is the practical walkthrough.

• Amazon Attribution (Brand Registry): Direct conversion tracking for external traffic to Amazon. Free.
• Google Analytics with UTM parameters: Track external traffic to your website.
• Run both for 60-90 days minimum. Less time produces noisy data.
• Compare conversion rate, average order value, net margin per channel.
• Pick the channel that delivers more revenue per dollar of external traffic acquisition.

Hybrid channel mix in practice

Most brands do not pick one channel; they run both with traffic split by source. Common hybrid patterns:

• Email to existing customers: Drive to website (highest margin; existing trust).
• Cold paid Facebook/Instagram ads: Drive to Amazon (Prime trust converts cold traffic).
• Brand site organic content: Mix of both; lead with Amazon link plus website link as secondary.
• Influencer partnerships: Usually Amazon (Amazon Attribution captures bonus; conversion typically better).
• Returning customer SMS/push: Drive to website (warmest audience; highest margin per sale).

The pattern: cold traffic to Amazon (where trust converts), warm traffic to website (where margin compounds). Most successful brands use both channels in this split.

How to build the website over time without losing Amazon momentum

Brands shifting from Amazon-heavy to balanced multi-channel often fear cannibalizing Amazon sales. Four moves protect Amazon while building website:

• Position website as the premium experience, not the discount channel. Same SKU price; better packaging, faster customer service, bundle offerings. Amazon volume protected.
• Use email marketing for repeat purchase to website only. First-time buyers go to Amazon (Prime trust); returning buyers go to website (margin compounds).
• Build content that ranks for informational keywords (not Amazon's commercial keywords). Content site captures Google traffic Amazon does not; no cannibalization.
• Track Amazon Sessions weekly during transition. If Amazon Sessions drop more than 10 percent month-over-month, slow website investment temporarily.

Conclusion

Whether to drive external traffic to Amazon or your own website depends on margin per channel and brand strategy. Amazon converts external traffic 3-5x better than standalone websites but charges 15-35 percent in fees; Brand Referral Bonus (10 percent for Brand Registry) offsets meaningfully. Your own website preserves full margin but requires email list and brand authority to convert at acceptable rates. Most successful brands use both with the split shifting from Amazon-heavy at launch to balanced at mature stage. Strong copy needs strong images; our Amazon Image Generator handles the parallel visual work.

The honest priority: calculate net margin per channel before choosing. Run Amazon Attribution and Google Analytics tracking for 60-90 days; pick the channel that delivers more revenue per traffic dollar. Pair this with our deeper reads on amazon ads online advertising for businesses of all, what is the right way to drive external traffic to, and the supporting how to optimize product listings for better sales guide.

References

1. Amazon Ads: Help Center (Amazon Attribution)
2. Sell on Amazon: 7 Ways to Improve Your Product Search Rankings